Your First Visit to My Cookie Dough: A Sweet Guide to What to Order
Walking into My Cookie Dough for the first time? With so many tempting desserts on the menu, choosing just one might be the hardest part!
From warm, soft cookie dough and creamy ice cream to indulgent sundaes, layered stacks and thick milkshakes, there's something for every kind of dessert lover.
Not sure where to begin? Here's a friendly guide to help you find your perfect sweet treat.

1. Cookie Dough Bases: Where the Magic Begins
At the heart of My Cookie Dough is its signature cookie dough, made using the brand's own recipe.
With six different cookie dough bases to choose from, you can explore different flavours and textures depending on your preferences.
Unlike traditional crunchy cookies, the cookie dough desserts are all about that warm, soft, comforting texture. Pair them with cold vanilla ice cream, and you get the combination that inspired the original My Cookie Dough concept.
Our recommendation: If you're visiting for the first time, start with
a classic cookie dough and vanilla ice cream combination. It's simple, delicious and lets you appreciate the contrast between warm dough and cool, creamy ice cream.
2. Sundaes: For the Ice Cream Lovers
If you love ice cream just as much as cookies, the sundaes are a great place to start.
These desserts bring together soft ice cream, pieces of cookie dough, sauces and sweet toppings, creating a combination of creamy, chewy and chocolatey textures.
One tempting choice is the Kinder Bueno Sundae, featuring cookie dough pieces, smooth ice cream and Kinder-inspired flavours.
Our recommendation: Choose a sundae if you prefer a cooler, creamier dessert rather than a primarily warm cookie dough experience. It's especially appealing if you enjoy chocolate and ice cream together.
3. Stacks: For Those Who Want Something Extra
Looking for a dessert that's a little more indulgent? Meet the stacks!
Stacks take the cookie dough experience to another level by combining layers of cookie dough with sauces, toppings and ice cream.
Depending on your favourite flavours, you can explore options such as Dark Chocolate, Bueno, Pistachio, Banana Pudding or Kinder and Nutella combinations.
Our recommendation: Chocolate lovers should explore the Dark Chocolate or Bueno options. If you're interested in something a little different, pistachio offers a nutty flavour, while banana pudding brings a softer, creamier dessert profile.
Stacks are a great choice when you're in the mood for a rich dessert with plenty of flavour in every bite.
4. Milkshakes: A Sweet Treat You Can Sip
Sometimes, you're craving something sweet but don't necessarily want a dessert you need a spoon to enjoy.
That's where the milkshakes come in!
My Cookie Dough's milkshakes are thick, rich and creamy, with a smooth texture that makes them feel like a dessert in a glass.
If you're a fan of caramel, a caramel milkshake is a tempting option to try.
Our recommendation: Order a milkshake on its own for a refreshing sweet treat, or pair one with a cookie dough dessert if you're sharing with someone.
What Should You Order on Your First Visit?
Still undecided? Here's a quick guide based on your cravings:
For the classic experience: Warm cookie dough with vanilla ice cream.
For Kinder Bueno fans: The Kinder Bueno Sundae, with creamy ice cream and cookie dough pieces.
For serious chocolate lovers: A Dark Chocolate or Kinder and Nutella Stack.
For something different: A Pistachio or Banana Pudding Stack.
For those who prefer sipping their dessert: A thick, creamy milkshake.
A Few Sweet Tips Before You Order
If it's your first visit, think about whether you prefer chocolatey, nutty, fruity or creamy flavours. That will make choosing much easier.
Love contrasting temperatures? Go for warm cookie dough with ice cream. Prefer lots of toppings and layers? Try a stack. Want something cooler and lighter in texture? A sundae might be your favourite.
And if you're visiting with friends, consider choosing different desserts and sharing. It's a great way to discover more of the menu without having to settle on just one flavour.
Ready to Discover Your Favourite?
What started as a simple Friday-night treat between two food science students in Cardiff has grown into an international dessert concept, bringing warm cookie dough creations to sweet-toothed visitors around the world.
Today, My Cookie Dough Cyprus welcomes dessert lovers at Protaras, Ayia Napa, Kapparis, Nicosia Mall and Mall of Cyprus, with a new location at My Mall Limassol coming soon.
Whether you're trying cookie dough for the first time or already know your favourite combination, there's always another flavour worth discovering.
The only question is: which one will you try first?

